Social Media for Insurance Agents: A Step-by-Step Guide for Better Results

Without a Strategy, Social Media is Just Noise. Social media for insurance agents isn’t just a fancy trend or something you have to do—it’s a critical marketing tool. But too many agents treat it as an afterthought, posting sporadically with no clear direction. The result? No engagement. No leads. Just crickets.
Sound familiar?
Here’s the truth: Social media without a strategy is like cold calling without a script—you’re just hoping for the best. A well-thought-out social media strategy can position your agency as an authority, deepen client relationships, and drive real business. But it requires more than occasional posts and random engagement. It requires purpose, consistency, and execution.
This guide will show you how to build a results-driven strategy for your agency’s social media. If this is new to your agency, or you’re just starting your insurance agency, it will help you set a strong foundation. If you’ve already been active but haven’t seen results, this will help you recalibrate.
Step 1: Define Your Goals—Because ‘Being Active’ is Not a Strategy
Before you post a single thing, ask yourself: What does success look like?
Social media for insurance agents isn’t a one-size-fits-all tool. Like any other business, your objectives will determine your content strategy, engagement tactics, and even which platforms you should focus on. Common goals include:
- Brand Awareness: Position your agency as the go-to expert in your niche.
- Client Retention: Strengthen relationships through education and engagement.
- Lead Generation: Turn social traffic into inquiries and sales.
- Recruiting: Attract new talent and independent agents to your agency.
Every post, interaction, and campaign should be tied back to one or more of these goals. If it doesn’t serve a purpose, it doesn’t belong in your content plan.
Pro Tip: Keep your goals measurable. Instead of “increase engagement,” aim for “boost engagement by 20% in three months.” Track progress and adjust accordingly.
Step 2: Pick the Right Platforms—You Don’t Need to Be Everywhere
One of the biggest mistakes in social media a business can make is trying to be active on every platform. The reality? Not all platforms will serve your business equally. Choose wisely based on where your audience actually spends time:
- Facebook & Instagram: Great for local branding, client engagement, and community involvement.
- LinkedIn: Essential for B2B connections, networking, and positioning your agency as an industry expert.
- X (formerly Twitter): Best for quick insights, industry trends, and real-time interactions.
- YouTube & TikTok: If video content is part of your strategy, these platforms offer huge organic reach.
Pro Tip: If you’re just starting out, focus on one or two platforms and master them before expanding. Consistency and engagement on a few platforms will yield far better results than spreading yourself too thin.
Step 3: Create Content That Connects—Not Just Sells
Nobody logs onto their social media account looking to learn about insurance. Get real. No, they log on to be informed, entertained, or inspired. The key to social media success? Become a valuable resource, not just another salesperson.
The “Rule of Thirds” for Content Strategy:
- One-third educational: Answer common insurance questions, provide tips, and share industry insights.
- One-third engaging: Share behind-the-scenes content, community involvement, or client testimonials.
- One-third promotional: Highlight your services, special offers, and calls to action—but sparingly.
Mixing up your content this way keeps your audience engaged while still driving business when the time is right.
Pro Tip: Leverage video. Short-form video (think Instagram Reels, TikTok, or YouTube Shorts) generates more engagement than text-based posts alone. Even a 30-second clip answering an insurance FAQ can go a long way.
Step 4: Post Consistently—Because Social Media is a Marathon, Not a Sprint
Inconsistent posting is the fastest way to kill your social media momentum. Social media for insurance agents works best when you show up consistently.
How Often Should You Post?
- Facebook & LinkedIn: 3-5 times per week
- Instagram & X: 5-7 times per week
- TikTok & YouTube Shorts: At least 2-3 times per week
Pro Tip: Use scheduling tools like HubSpot, Buffer, or Hootsuite to plan posts in advance and maintain consistency without having to be online 24/7.
Step 5: Engage With Your Audience—Don’t Just Broadcast
When you use Social media for your insurance agency, it isn’t just about posting—it’s about conversations.
- Respond to comments and messages quickly—within a few hours if possible.
- Ask questions in your posts to spark discussions.
- Engage with other local businesses and professionals to build community relationships.
- Share and comment on industry-relevant content to position your agency as an active participant in the space.
Pro Tip: Social listening tools like Brandwatch or Mention can help you track brand mentions and conversations in real-time so you never miss an opportunity to engage.
Step 6: Track, Measure, and Adjust—Because Guesswork is Not a Strategy
You can’t improve what you don’t measure. Every social media effort should be tracked so you know what’s working and what’s not.
Key Metrics to Watch:
- Engagement Rate: Likes, comments, shares, and clicks.
- Reach & Impressions: How many people see your posts?
- Website Traffic: How many visits come from social media?
- Lead Conversions: How many social visitors turn into inquiries or policyholders?
Most platforms have built-in analytics tools (Facebook Insights, LinkedIn Analytics, etc.), and you can also track conversions using Google Analytics or HubSpot.
Pro Tip: Review your social media performance monthly. Double down on what’s working and tweak what’s underperforming.
Final Thoughts: Build Relationships, Not Just Followers
Social media for insurance agents isn’t about follower counts—it’s about building trust, credibility, and relationships. When done right, it creates brand advocates, keeps clients engaged, and generates steady business over time.
By following this strategy—defining goals, choosing the right platforms, creating engaging content, posting consistently, interacting with your audience, and tracking results—you’ll build a social media presence that actually drives results.
Now, Take Action:
- Review your current social media efforts—what’s working, what’s not?
- Choose one or two platforms to focus on and create a 30-day content plan.
- Start small, stay consistent, and refine your strategy based on data.
Looking for automated marketing tools to streamline your social media efforts? Let’s talk about how HubSpot and other automation solutions can take your agency’s marketing to the next level. Reach out today!
Interested In Membership?
Learn how membership will bring new growth opportunities, new carrier relationships, and new energy to growing your business